Nature is circular

Use Circular Design To Reverse Harm

by Kasturika | | 18 min read
363 shares

Nature is circular. Nothing ever goes to waste. The banana peel we discard degrades into nutritious compost for plants. Even the remains of deceased animals and humans disintegrate into the soil. Human engineering and design, on the other hand, are linear processes. And that has put us on a one-way highway to a global wasteland. How can we move from linear economies to a more natural, circular one? Grand old man of UX design, Don Norman answers in this video.

Show Hide video transcript
  1. 00:00:00 --> 00:00:34

    Today when we manufacture things, we use what is called a *linear economy*. First, we go and get the materials, and this often requires using big machines to mine the Earth for the materials, or maybe if it's biological materials, we have to have big farms or big growing areas where we grow the materials we're going to use. Then we go into the manufacturing plant where we have to prepare the raw materials

  2. 00:00:34 --> 00:01:03

    to be usable. And that creates a lot of waste and it takes a lot of power and emits a lot of stuff into the atmosphere and the land and the ocean. And then we actually have to manufacture the thing we care about – again, more waste. And then we have to transport it to the place where it's purchased and used and during the usage, more waste, and then afterwards, what do we do? We usually throw them away, or we sometimes try to recycle.

  3. 00:01:03 --> 00:01:33

    But recycling is actually not an answer to the problem because it's very expensive to recycle the materials that we use today and quite often it costs more money to recycle and to reuse than to use brand-new materials. So, recycling is not very sustainable. It doesn't mean we shouldn't do it, but it's not the answer to the problem. Remember what nature does. Here, nature provides a very convenient package.

  4. 00:01:33 --> 00:02:02

    Look – I can take it home this way from the store; I don't need a plastic bag. It's robust, it's pretty protective, and it is reusable. First of all, I eat the stuff in the middle – the banana. And, second of all, I throw away the peel, but if I throw it away into a compost pile, it becomes great nutrients or even if I just throw it into the ground where there are plants, it takes a bit longer for it to decompose this way,

  5. 00:02:02 --> 00:02:31

    but it will eventually decompose and  be useful material for the growing of plants. And nature does this. Almost everything in nature is reusable. Our bodies themselves are reusable. How could we manufacture in ways that  are like that? Well, this requires us to manufacture *differently*. And it's going to require a different model for business. But the model has to be *circular*.  That is to say, the first time, yes,  

  6. 00:02:31 --> 00:03:05

    I take out raw material from the Earth  and I manufacture and I make an object.  But when I resell it, when I give it to people to be used, then the circle begins, because if it breaks, we repair it; if it runs out of power, we have a device that easily recharges. Well, suppose it's a cell phone and a new  technology comes about that gives us higher bandwidth – do I have to throw away the cell phone or the mobile that I have?

  7. 00:03:05 --> 00:03:35

    No. I should be able to open it up and maybe replace the wireless component with the new component, that gives me the new skills, the new technology. Or if the cameras get better – I've had the phone for five years and now the cameras are much better – I would like to upgrade the camera, I can open it up to pull out the old camera and put it in a new camera. Why can't I continually upgrade this equipment that we have instead of buying a new one?

  8. 00:03:35 --> 00:04:04

    So, what do we do when a product has reached the end of its life? What do we do to complete the circle? Well, there are companies that are already doing that – making things so that when it's reached the end of its useful life, we can take it apart and reuse the components. One example is Canon, the company  that makes cameras, and in this case laser printers for your computer, have already done this with the toner,

  9. 00:04:04 --> 00:04:32

    the material within the laser printer that makes the dots on the paper, the colors and the black and white that makes the pictures and the words visible. Every laser printer has in it a bunch of cartridges that contain the toner. And when the toner is empty because we printed so many pages, what do you do with this cartridge? Canon says, 'Oh, buy a new one and take it out of  the box

  10. 00:04:32 --> 00:05:05

    and take the old one and put it into the box.' And we insert the new cartridge back into the printer and we take the old cartridge and we mail it back to Canon, and Canon even pays the postage. And Canon says, "We have designed these cartridges so that every part of it can be reused either in a new cartridge or in other things that can use the very same parts." And they advertise that we have  no waste in recycling, reusing, repairing.

  11. 00:05:05 --> 00:05:30

    That's the circular economy – designing things so that in the end *everything can be reused*, if not for the same product, then for other, similar or even different  products. Remember the paper cup used for coffee. It can't be reused because it has a plastic  lining inside, and that is very difficult to remove.

  12. 00:05:30 --> 00:06:00

    But what if it didn't have a plastic lining? What if we could make a paper cup   that was actually okay to put in hot liquids? Now, it turns out there are ways of doing this and there are some companies doing this already. If that were the case, this would be completely circular. We get the material from trees  or plants to make the paper; we make the coffee cup. When we're finished with a coffee cup, we discard it, but it can be reused.

  13. 00:06:00 --> 00:06:31

    We can shred the coffee cup and use the pulp to make another coffee cup and another coffee cup and another coffee cup. It simply requires thinking hard about materials and making sure that they can be reused. One of the problems with modern manufacturing and modern design is that in the attempt to make something that's so small and so thin and so lightweight, it's that we've made it so that it is basically impossible to reuse

  14. 00:06:31 --> 00:07:05

    because we've taken many, many different kinds of materials and bonded them together in a way that is difficult or even impossible to separate. We've made wonderful devices that are wonderful to feel, wonderful to touch, wonderful to look at because they're made out of multiple materials, put together in a way that, well, each of the materials alone could be reused, but when they're combined together, it's  impossible or too expensive to take them apart. We have to stop that; so, here's where  design plays a very important role.

Circular Design

The circular economy requires circular design. The three principles of circular design are:

  1. Eliminate waste and pollution, including toxic substances that harm the soil and water and reduce emissions. Design plays a key role here. Almost every product generates waste, and so we need to redesign everything. 

  2. Circulate products and materials at their highest value for as long as possible. For example, we can build machines to last a long time and be dismantlable so their parts can be repaired easily and reused in new products. They should be recyclable so that no more resources are mined from the earth.

  3. Regenerate natural systems by returning natural resources to the earth. For example, food waste can help regenerate farmlands.

The circular economy butterfly diagram by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation illustrates how we can minimize waste using both renewable and non-renewable materials.

© Ellen MacArthur Foundation, Fair Use

The Take Away

Today, we have a linear economy. We collect raw materials from the earth, and we transform the raw materials into products which we sell to consumers. When the products are not working any longer or when they’re not trendy anymore, we consumers discard them as waste. 

A circular economy generates zero waste. Once a component enters the cycle, it continues to be used for a long time. And once it is unusable, it can degrade naturally.

To create a circular economy, people from different disciplines must work together, think strategically about materials, and ensure they are reusable. Sustainable design is paramount. Today, manufacturers combine different natural materials to create artificial materials. While the original components of these new materials degrade naturally, the artificial ones, once made, cannot be unmade. One of the biggest challenges is the conflict between circular manufacturing and aesthetics. In an attempt to make something that's small, thin and lightweight, companies have made it impossible to reuse materials because they've combined them in ways that are difficult or even impossible to separate. This conflict between aesthetics and circularity is challenging, but with concerted action, an excellent opportunity for businesses. 

References and Where to Learn More

Learn more about circular design in Don Norman’s book Design for a Better World: Meaningful, Sustainable, Humanity Centered.

Additional resources from the book “Design for a Better World” are available at the Resources for DBW website.

Read more articles and essays by Don Norman on JND.org.

Watch this video interview with Dame Ellen MacArthur on What is a circular economy? (~10 minutes)

See more about Circular Economy here.

Get Weekly Design Insights

Join 315,762 designers who get useful UX / UI Design tips from our newsletter.
A valid email address is required.
363 shares

Open Access—Link to us!

We believe in Open Access and the democratization of knowledge. Unfortunately, world-class educational materials such as this page are normally hidden behind paywalls or in expensive textbooks.

If you want this to change, , link to us, or join us to help us democratize design knowledge!

Privacy Settings
By using this site, you accept our Cookie Policy and Terms of Use.

Share Knowledge, Get Respect!

Share on:

or copy link

Cite according to academic standards

Simply copy and paste the text below into your bibliographic reference list, onto your blog, or anywhere else. You can also just hyperlink to this article.

Kasturika, K. (2023, March 21). Use Circular Design To Reverse Harm. Interaction Design Foundation - IxDF.

New to UX Design? We're Giving You a Free eBook!

The Basics of User Experience Design

Download our free ebook “The Basics of User Experience Design” to learn about core concepts of UX design.

In 9 chapters, we'll cover: conducting user interviews, design thinking, interaction design, mobile UX design, usability, UX research, and many more!

A valid email address is required.
315,762 designers enjoy our newsletter—sure you don't want to receive it?