Skeuomorphism is dead, long live skeuomorphism

- 1.1k shares
- 4 years ago
Flat design is a user interface design style that uses simple, two-dimensional elements and bright colors. It is often contrasted to the skeuomorphic style that gives the illusion of three dimensions through copying real-life properties. Its popularity became prominent with the release of Windows 8, Apple’s iOS 7, and Google’s Material Design, all of which utilize flat design.
Flat design was originally developed for responsive design, where a website’s content scales smoothly depending on the device’s screen size. With the use of simple shapes and minimal textures, flat design ensures that responsive designs work well and load fast (especially important since mobile devices have slower internet speeds). By reducing the amount of visual noise (in the form of textures and shadows), flat design provides users with a streamlined and more optimal user experience.
However, despite its popularity, flat design also has drawbacks regarding the user experience. The absence of three-dimensional effects (e.g., drop shadows) takes away the cues that indicate how a user can interact with a design. For example, buttons in the flat design style do not appear distinct from other visual elements on a webpage, and therefore do not appear clickable. Because of this danger, flat design is increasingly applied in a more balanced way, often referred to as “flat design 2.0” or “almost flat design.” This trend takes the clean and simple visuals from flat design and adds some subtle skeuomorphic qualities such as color variations and shadows. With this increased depth and dimension, visual variety increases and usability improves. For instance, Google’s Material Design and Apple’s iOS interfaces heavily use shadows and/or blurring effects to make their interfaces more intuitive to use.
A flat design style is a clean and minimalist graphic style that uses 2D elements with bright colors. It focuses on minimalism, functionality, and usability and uses no shading or extra details to make visuals look 3D. It prioritizes a clean and organized layout to minimize distractions and improve clarity.
A flat design style aims to keep things straightforward without any fancy extras. It is about simplicity, with a modern look that is practical and user-friendly in digital apps.
A flat design image is a simple picture made in the flat design style. It uses basic shapes, bright colors, and simple typography. You might see these images on websites, apps, or printed materials. Flat design images keep things neat, focusing on how easy it is to use them. They help share information in a clear and user-friendly way. So, it is a clean and straightforward picture that makes things easy to understand, whether on a website or using an app.
This video discusses various examples of different visual frameworks. Jump ahead to 9.20 to catch an example of a flat design.
Hello and welcome to this UX Daily video in which we'll be discovering a design pattern that is very useful when you're creating the page structure for your project – the *visual framework*. My name is Priscilla Esser, and I will be discussing the tricks of the trade from WordPress template developers and other seasoned interface designers. And I will show you how they create consistency in page layouts. One of the essential elements of creating the best results for visual frameworks is something called *visual hierarchy*.
In this video, I will help you understand what visual hierarchy is and how to use that to create a proper visual framework. The visual framework is all about creating visual consistency throughout the user experience. To illustrate the importance of this consistency, just think about the simple task of finding your way back to the homepage of a website. We're all used to having the company logo in the top navigation bar to be the homepage link. Just have a look at this example from the Interaction Design Foundation website.
But what if you designed a website with multiple pages that all have this link at another location? How would it impact your experience if the logo was placed in the *footer* of the website, for example? Probably not that positive, right? You would have to scan each page separately for visual cues that indicate this functionality, adding to your mental burden. The solution is creating a consistent visual framework for all pages of your website or application. It's a framework of visual elements, colors and typography that forms a basic layout.
This layout gives you sufficient structure to create consistent pages. But it also offers enough flexibility to handle different content types. In this example, you can see how the two pages of the garden supply website are consistent in the placement of the logo, headers, menu items, and search boxes. At the same time, the pages differ in the type of content they provide. The page on the left is clearly intended to inspire people with a large image and top categories, whereas the page on the right is giving an overview of available products in the online store.
Notice how the consistent elements of the visual framework seem to be more in the *background* but the content itself appears to be more in the *foreground*. This is what a good visual framework can do for your design. It can help let your content stand out and shine. A great example of a visual framework in practice is a WordPress theme. These themes allow you to add any content you desire to create your own website based on the chosen visual framework. As most people aren't designers, this is a great way of making sure a website has good consistency
and visual appeal. But since you are a designer, we'll use this example to see how it's done. So, let's have a look at the WordPress theme we see in this example. The visual elements that have been predetermined by the theme developers are the header size, placement of menu items and search box. Also, the structure of the blog post has given us a three-column layout with white blocks on a grayish background. The typography is set, as is color use, the way images are shown, etc.
Naturally, everyone wants to personalize their website, so most elements are customizable. However, the theme developers do present a good visual framework that you can take as a starting point. Now, if we have a further look at this example, we see that the theme developers have also provided alternative ways to present different types of content while keeping the visual framework intact. The screenshot here shows how a side menu bar can be combined with a wider content block for blog posts. The user does not get confused by this change
as the visual framework ensures that the major elements can be found at the same place and the overall look and feel is consistent. To create a visual framework, these are the steps that you should take. First, determine what types of content you need to place on different pages of your interface and what tasks a user will most likely want to perform often. Then, based on type of content and task, determine what user interface design patterns will be present across all pages
– for example, a top-left navigation bar, a search box, a list or a dropdown menu of categories. Next, you should organize all returning visual elements on the page and indicate where content should go. Think about what element should go into the header area – most important – what, if anything, could be made accessible in sidebar, and what is more suitable for a footer area. Also, depending on the types of content, determine if you want to use multiple columns or not. Ensure that content has sufficient space to attract attention. When all elements have found a place on your page, you can decide on a more detailed level what colors and
fonts you want to use. This is where the framework becomes personalized to the brand or company you're designing for. You can have some fun here, but you can also use color and fonts to guide people in the right direction, as we will see in a few minutes when we dive into the topic of visual hierarchy. But let's first finish the topic of implementation of the visual framework. While you're taking the first couple of steps in creating this framework, it's very useful to make wireframes to position the various elements in a consistent layout.
Without emphasizing the visual appeal of color and images at first, it's much easier to shuffle design elements such as blocks of content and other design patterns around to create a good overview and focus on usability. In wireframes, you simply create placeholders for pieces of content and visual elements. It's a great way to do some early user testing by creating a paper prototype or creating a clickable prototype with wireframing software such as Balsamiq.
The example you see here is actually created in Balsamiq, but many other wireframing applications are available. Of course, you might just prefer the old-fashioned paper-and-pencil way to get the creative juices flowing, which is perfectly OK. After creating the wireframes in the first couple of steps of implementing a visual framework and focusing on more graphic design elements such as color and typography, you may want to consider creating a style guide to report the design decisions you made here. Style guides give all the visual elements and rules for implementing them. It increases the uniformity and consistency you're looking for with a visual framework,
but enables future extensions of your framework by others. This way, you ensure that when a client will not hire you five years from now to add to the website you designed for them, your efforts will not have been in vain and the new additions will remain consistent with your original intentions. As you can see here, major companies like Yelp provide their style guide as a resource for designers, product managers and developers. It serves as a common language to create brand consistency and a good user experience.
Now, the main problem with visual frameworks is that when the initial design isn't very good, it will continue to bite you in the behind throughout all of the pages. So, how do you get the initial framework just right? Let's start by deciding what we consider a good page layout. Here's what I think: First of all, a page should invite and enable the user to accomplish the task they want in a way that doesn't take too much effort. Secondly, it should allow the page owner to effectively communicate what they want
whether it is who they are or what the latest addition to the collection is. So, there's two sides of the coin, but they both revolve around seeing what you need to see to achieve a goal. Let's take a look at an example of a page that *doesn't* use visual hierarchy to achieve these results. It's actually a newspaper page from many years ago. Notice how all visual elements seem to be *equally important*. This was very common back in the day. But now, we're used to having things displayed in a much more *supportive* way.
Now, take this example. Here, some blocks of content instantly stand out to you and some seem to be more in the background. I imagine that if you're looking for a specific piece of information, this newspaper will help you do that much faster than the previous one. The designers of this page have played with visual elements to make some bits stand out more than others. Can you identify what design decisions they've made to achieve this? First, they've played with *size*.
Take a moment to see all of the different sizes they used to create hierarchy in the content. They also used *color* to make some text stand out more than others. Do you see how they did that? Let's have a closer look at how this works in the next slide. Visual hierarchy is all about *setting priorities*. What do you want people to see first, while they're merely glancing over your design? And then, when they *like* what they see, people will start *skimming*. This will make another level of the hierarchy stand out to them. This is often a bit smaller with less energizing colors or less contrast in the background
like the second line of gray text you see in this image. Only when people *consciously* take the time to start reading the text will text that is thinner, smaller and less contrasted be noticed. Now, where it becomes fun for you as a designer is when you start playing with these visual elements to attract attention to the right places. Using an *anomaly* to the standard visual hierarchy of a page layout, like the bullet text in this example, will give you control over the users' path of attention. It really draws the eye of the user to this text.
In this case, we say that the bold text has more *visual weight* than the regular text. Generally speaking, more visual weight attracts more attention when combined with less heavy elements. Let's have a look at some examples of visual frameworks to see if we can recognize how the designers have used visual hierarchy. Here, we're looking at a screenshot from the Dropbox website. Some visual hierarchy is achieved by making the heading bigger or bolder than the remaining text and by using blue as a contrast color. But all in all, I think this is rather a flat design without big differences in visual weight.
When we turn to this example, which is comparable in that it shows a pricing scheme for cloud-based storage subscriptions, we see that a stronger visual hierarchy is used. The most popular pricing option stands out more, not just because it's labeled "most popular", but also because the most popular option seems to burst out of the visual structure that the others abide by. To achieve this, the designs have used brighter colors and they allow the best option to take up more space in the layout of the page.
And as you can see, they do this *consistently* as it's not just the boxed area at the top of the page but also the features description which seems to grow heavier for each step it takes. The previous examples were both based on visual frameworks that depend heavily on a white background and fairly minimalist text options. Here, we take a different turn and show you an example that uses many more images and colors to present the content. A visual framework is implemented with a top navigation bar, a large area to showcase highlighted talks
and a row system with room for six talks per category. The visual hierarchy that is used to support this framework uses *size* – so, the biggest talk is perceived as the most important, especially since the title of this talk has the biggest font size – and *contrast*. The two other talks in the talk area really stand out from the background, making it look quite important as well. Since most users will visit this website to browse for interesting talks to watch and to get inspired, it's perfectly fine to have size and contrast *competing* with each other.
When users would visit a website with a *single purpose*, you might want to combine size and contrast to give a certain element *all* of the visual weight. Now, let's analyze this example together. Which element is the highest in the visual hierarchy and what stands out to you first? In this case, it's a combination of contrast and color. The block of content on the top-left side has the most visual weight. So, what is then the element *lowest* in the hierarchy in the screenshot and what has the lowest visual weight is in that respect the absolute opposite of the heavy black-and-yellow box
in my opinion is the category bar that says "Entertainment, Products, People, Fashion, Music" and so on. It has a small font size and is grey on a white background. It attracts the least attention. In this video, we had a look at a very powerful way to create consistency in your designs: the visual framework. We've seen that consistency helps users to find their way on a website or application and increases the usability. To create a good visual framework, you need to determine all of the elements that you need to place on the page and find the right location for them.
You can start out by drawing wireframes that focus on the placement before continuing with the style guide, which also describes the colors and fonts that need to be used consistently. When a visual framework is well documented, it helps future designers to continue the look and feel in new pages or products. A good visual framework also takes into account the visual hierarchy of a page. By using colors and sizes, you can give certain elements on a page more visual weight than others – which makes them attract more attention and appear more important.
The visual framework and visual hierarchy give you as a designer great input to play around and have some fun with visual elements while ensuring that you create high-quality designs.
The flat design comes with a range of benefits:
It ensures consistent application across platforms for a unified brand image.
User-friendly icons aid in better understanding and interaction.
Flat design reduces cognitive load by avoiding complex textures and shadows.
It offers a contemporary aesthetic aligned with modern design trends.
Easier maintenance and updates due to design simplicity.
Simplifies visual elements for a clean interface.
It contributes to faster loading times with simple shapes and details.
Flat design theory uses clean, white space, crisp edges, bright colors, and two-dimensional illustrations. The goal is to create a modern and straightforward experience for users on computers or phones.
Flat design became famous as a cleaner alternative to skeuomorphism. The article discusses the evolution, decline, and return of skeuomorphism in design. It also highlights the rise of flat design as a response to the issues with skeuomorphism, emphasizing visual clarity and simplicity.
Modern flat design, or "flat design 2.0," is an evolution of traditional principles. Modern flat retains the simple, two-dimensional elements, and bright color palettes characteristic of flat design. However, it has subtle additions to address its drawbacks regarding the user experience.
Some notable features of modern flat design are:
Incorporates subtle shadows or gradients.
Prioritizes responsiveness, ensuring adaptability to various screen sizes and devices.
Employs layering techniques to establish a sense of hierarchy and improve user interaction.
Flat design is widely used across various industries and platforms, seeking clean and modern aesthetics. Major tech players like Microsoft, Apple, and Google have incorporated flat design principles into their operating systems.
Social media platforms, professional networking sites, and web development tools also leverage flat design for its visually appealing qualities. The design trend is not limited to specific industries. Diverse organizations striving for a streamlined and contemporary visual experience in their products and interfaces are embracing it.
Yes, the flat design remains a prevalent and influential trend. It gained widespread recognition as a design style in 2012 and 2013, notably with the releases of Windows 8 and iOS 7. Since then, flat design has remained a prominent and recognizable trend.
"Flat design 2.0" or "almost flat design" are more balanced ways to use flat design. Major tech companies and web and app designers highly utilize these.
A flat design on a website is a modern and clean style. Bright colors, simple shapes, and easy-to-read fonts characterize it. Here are six signs to recognize flat design:
Bright Contrasts: It uses vivid colors to guide users visually.
Simple Shapes: No fancy, realistic images—just basic shapes.
Easy Fonts: It prefers simple, fast-loading fonts, like sans-serif.
White Spaces: Blank areas help focus and make websites easier to read.
Grid Layouts: It often follows a symmetrical grid for organization.
Plain and Simple: Symbolic icons, basic shapes, no textures, and no fancy color blends.
Here are some simple steps to make a flat design:
Utilize basic iconography and design simple and recognizable icons.
Opt for a bright and contrasting color palette. Limit the number of colors for simplicity.
Limit your typography choices and opt for simple, legible fonts.
There are a lot of fonts. If you go to a design tool, you'll notice that there are hundreds or dozens of different fonts. But most of them are useless, and most of them are fonts that you should never use. So, if you're just starting and if you're not really comfortable with design yet, you should completely always avoid decorative fonts, handwriting fonts, and in most cases serif fonts as well. And I know this sounds really crazy and over the top, but most serif fonts are not really that easy to work with,
and you need to be able to set the spacing and leading, kerning and everything in the proper way for them for the digital interfaces to work well. So, it's best for the initial time that you're working on your designs to just *stick to sans serifs*. And I have a short list of fonts that are basically safe. There is a couple more – you can find them somewhere, but you don't really need a lot more when you're starting. If you're testing your design skills, if you're learning design,
a couple of these fonts are all you need, and especially right now if you're looking for a good free font, I would recommend Plus Jakarta Sans because it's one of the better-looking fonts out there, it's completely free and it looks good in most scenarios. So, don't use those decorative fonts, don't use those fancy fonts, because the simpler they are, the better they look. And another thing about font is that somehow people have this notion of thinking
that if a font is thin or light, it's kind of synonymous with minimal design, and that minimal design like the Swiss style – you know – super-minimal design was actually pushed by Apple at some point with iOS 7 if what I remember is correct, but they quickly reverted to that because those fonts don't really display well on most screens. They are too thin, and they are basically not readable. So, just *go for regular and bold in most cases*
and don't go for those thin and light fonts in your designs. Because as you can see here, it's just a lot easier to read the window on the right side. And also, if you're starting, don't create a ton of different font sizes. You should have like a heading, a smaller heading and everything else as just one font. So, in practice this is another like a pop-up window that shows a couple of different elements, and we have just one size for the title.
And then the second size with different weights – one is bold; the rest are regular – is used for all of the other things. And if we switch it to four different font sizes on a small window like that, it's going to make our brain think, 'Oh my God – I need to process all that!' So, *just make it easy for the brain and just switch it to a much simpler option* because it's just always going to work better, and of course, a lot of the rules that I'm going to share with you are rules that you can break once you feel confident about breaking them.
So, *when you're just starting, just don't break them*.
Establish a visual hierarchy through size, color, and placement.
Eliminate gradients, realistic textures, and shadows.
Maintain consistency in design elements and employ a consistent grid system for alignment.
Ensure the design adapts well to different screen sizes and test on various devices for responsiveness.
The course "Visual Design: The Ultimate Guide" comprehensively explores flat design and visual principles. It will enhance your understanding of visual principles, color theory, typography, and grid systems. The course comprises four lessons and provides practical applications:
Learn to differentiate between visual design elements and principles. Apply this knowledge by deconstructing well-known designs.
Explore color theory, schemes, and systems. Gain a cultural understanding of color symbolism and its context of use.
Understand the anatomy of type, classifications, styles, and typographic terms. Learn some practical tips for selecting and combining typefaces.
Recognize the significance of grid systems in providing a structure within the design. Unveil different types and practical applications to enhance design work.
Remember, the more you learn about design, the more you make yourself valuable.
Improve your UX / UI Design skills and grow your career! Join IxDF now!
You earned your gift with a perfect score! Let us send it to you.
We've emailed your gift to name@email.com.
Improve your UX / UI Design skills and grow your career! Join IxDF now!
Here's the entire UX literature on Flat Design by the Interaction Design Foundation, collated in one place:
Take a deep dive into Flat Design with our course Visual Design: The Ultimate Guide .
In this course, you will gain a holistic understanding of visual design and increase your knowledge of visual principles, color theory, typography, grid systems and history. You’ll also learn why visual design is so important, how history influences the present, and practical applications to improve your own work. These insights will help you to achieve the best possible user experience.
In the first lesson, you’ll learn the difference between visual design elements and visual design principles. You’ll also learn how to effectively use visual design elements and principles by deconstructing several well-known designs.
In the second lesson, you’ll learn about the science and importance of color. You’ll gain a better understanding of color modes, color schemes and color systems. You’ll also learn how to confidently use color by understanding its cultural symbolism and context of use.
In the third lesson, you’ll learn best practices for designing with type and how to effectively use type for communication. We’ll provide you with a basic understanding of the anatomy of type, type classifications, type styles and typographic terms. You’ll also learn practical tips for selecting a typeface, when to mix typefaces and how to talk type with fellow designers.
In the final lesson, you’ll learn about grid systems and their importance in providing structure within design. You’ll also learn about the types of grid systems and how to effectively use grids to improve your work.
You’ll be taught by some of the world’s leading experts. The experts we’ve handpicked for you are the Vignelli Distinguished Professor of Design Emeritus at RIT R. Roger Remington, author of “American Modernism: Graphic Design, 1920 to 1960”; Co-founder of The Book Doctors Arielle Eckstut and leading color consultant Joann Eckstut, co-authors of “What Is Color?” and “The Secret Language of Color”; Award-winning designer and educator Mia Cinelli, TEDx speaker of “The Power of Typography”; Betty Cooke and William O. Steinmetz Design Chair at MICA Ellen Lupton, author of “Thinking with Type”; Chair of the Graphic + Interactive communication department at the Ringling School of Art and Design Kimberly Elam, author of "Grid Systems: Principles of Organizing Type.”
Throughout the course, we’ll supply you with lots of templates and step-by-step guides so you can go right out and use what you learn in your everyday practice.
In the “Build Your Portfolio Project: Redesign,” you’ll find a series of fun exercises that build upon one another and cover the visual design topics discussed. If you want to complete these optional exercises, you will get hands-on experience with the methods you learn and in the process you’ll create a case study for your portfolio which you can show your future employer or freelance customers.
You can also learn with your fellow course-takers and use the discussion forums to get feedback and inspire other people who are learning alongside you. You and your fellow course-takers have a huge knowledge and experience base between you, so we think you should take advantage of it whenever possible.
You earn a verifiable and industry-trusted Course Certificate once you’ve completed the course. You can highlight it on your resume, your LinkedIn profile or your website.
We believe in Open Access and the democratization of knowledge. Unfortunately, world-class educational materials such as this page are normally hidden behind paywalls or in expensive textbooks.
If you want this to change, , link to us, or join us to help us democratize design knowledge!